Friday July 30, 2010

Analysts Stand to Keep Earnings in Place

An influential group of analysts have said that dropping headline earnings figures from financial statements would be damaging to investors, reports Jennifer Hughes of the Financial Times.

An influential group of analysts have said that droppingheadline earnings figures from financial statements would be damaging toinvestors, reports Jennifer Hughes of the Financial Times.

According to Hughes, the International Accounting Standards Boardand its U.S.branch, the Financial Accounting Standards Board, are both in the midst ofcomposing proposals that would change the make-up of main financial statements, and both boards are to put out a discussion paper for comment next year.  One of the measures considered is the removalof earnings, also known as the “bottom line,” as it has been deemed too simplistic, and as a result of theintroduction of other comprehensive income, analysts are afraid it would impedetheir ability to gauge a company’s real performance by clouding it with otheritems.

In a letter to both the IASB and the FASB, members of theCorporate Reporting Users’ Forum, made up of senior research analysts from suchbanks and fun managers as Deutsche Bank, Merrill Lynch, Lehman Brothers andFidelity, said they disagree with the proposals that there should not be anearnings sub-total within a performance statement, as they find the “earningssub-total particularly useful in enabling management to communicate with us ata highly aggregated level.”

“We’re trying to phrase the letter on the basis we recognizethey haven’t come to a decision yet,” Peter Elwin, head of accounting andvaluation research at Cazenove, told FT. “But we are concerned that there might already be a momentum in aparticular director.”

Leave a Reply