Successors to Chandler Queue Up in Delaware
Chancellor William B. Chandler of the Delaware Court of Chancery resigned after 22 years of service in the widely influential business court, citing a desire to transition into the private sector. “I want to pursue new and exciting opportunities and challenges that are available to me,” said Chandler. “I also believe now is the time for me to seek greater financial rewards in the interest of my family.” His resignation has led to speculation that Vice Chancellor Leo E. Strine Jr. will replace him. Other candidates who submitted applications by the May 13th deadline include Sam Glasscock III, chancery court master; Delaware Superior Court Judge Mary M. Johnston; Richard E. Berl Jr. of Smith Feinberg McCartney & Berl; Kevin Brady of Connolly Bove Lodge & Hutz; Richard Forsten of Saul Ewing; Joel Friedlander of Bouchard Margules & Friedlander; and Bruce Silverstein of Young Conaway Stargatt & Taylor.
William B. Chandler III
The process of choosing Chandler’s successor got underway in May when the Delaware Judicial Nominating Commission, chaired by Andre G. Bouchard, managing partner at Bouchard Margules & Friedlander, issued a public notice soliciting candidates. The court is required by the state constitution to be bipartisan, and all candidates must be Delaware residents. Following interviews, the JNC would refer any finalists to Gov. Jack Markell, who would then recommend one candidate to the state Senate for approval.
The 60-year-old Chandler, the subject of a cover story in NACD Directorship (December 2010/January 2011), notified the Delaware governor in April he planned to resign to seek opportunities in the private sector. His last day on the court was expected to be June 17.
Franklin, Hockaday to Co-Chair BRC on Lead Directors
A group of more than 20 corporate directors and governance thought leaders convened this spring to initiate the 2011 Report of the NACD Blue Ribbon Commission on the Lead Director. Hosted by the NACD, the commissioners will leverage their years of experience to develop recommendations that will define and clarify the role of the lead director in the boardroom. The commission is co-chaired by Barbara Hackman Franklin, former U.S. Secretary of Commerce, and currently a director for Aetna and the Dow Chemical Company and chairman of the board for NACD; and Irvine Hockaday, director for Ford Motor Company, Estée Lauder and Crown Media Holdings. Holly Gregory, corporate partner at Weil, Gotshal & Manges, will serve as governance counsel to the commission.
“As boards rise in accountability and visibility, the role of the lead director has become increasingly important. Lead directors play a critical role in ensuring independence of thought and oversight, and help build consensus in the decision-making process,” said Ken Daly, president and CEO of NACD. “The diversity and depth of experience represented on this year’s commission provide a unique opportunity to study leading practices for the lead director position.”
The new commissioners will meet once more in June as they continue to collaborate on their recommendations. The report is scheduled for release at the NACD Annual Board Leadership Conference on October 2-4 in Washington, D.C.
Delaware VC Cuts Plaintiff Lawyer Fee
What did shareholder plaintiffs lawyers achieve in their litigation over an abandoned tender offer for shares of Sauer-Danfoss? Not much, according to a recent decision by Delaware Vice Chancellor J. Travis Laster. In fact, Laster found that the plaintiffs lawyers did so little of value that he slashed their fee request by 95 percent and awarded them just $75,000 of the $790,000 they asked for, according to Morris James’ Delaware Business Litigation Report. Wrote Laster: “Plaintiffs never engaged in meaningful litigation activity.”
Heidrick Study Finds Number of Directorships in Decline
New director appointments decreased 22 percent from 2009 to 2010, according to the new Heidrick & Struggles Board Monitor Fortune 500 quarterly trend report, with 279 new directors at the studied companies in 2010, down from 356 in 2009. In addition, only one-third of these appointees had non-CEO or –CFO backgrounds, reflecting the growing post-Dodd-Frank disclosure requirements. “The ongoing economic uncertainty is causing companies to lean towards those with top-job experience when they do make an appointment,” said Bonnie Gwin, the leadership advisory firm’s vice chairman and head of the North American Board Practice. Average director age remained at 57, and female placements increased slightly from 17.9 percent to 19.3 percent.
Outside CEOs Cost More, Perform Worse
CEOs promoted from within are more cost-effective and outperform their external counterparts, according to a study conducted by The Kelley School of Business at Indiana University in conjunction with A.T. Kearney, that examined 36 companies that had promoted internally between 1988 and 2007. It compared their performance with other S&P 500 companies that had chosen external candidates. The study found that none of the external CEOs’ companies performed better than the 36 identified companies, and the external CEOs commanded salaries that were 65 percent higher than those of CEOs recruited from within.
Transocean Execs Donate Safety Bonuses to Victims’ Families
After sparking public ire by rewarding executives with safety bonuses, five Transocean senior executives will donate $250,000 collectively to a fund for the families of victims of last year’s Deepwater Horizon explosion in the Gulf of Mexico. Transocean had given safety bonuses because the company had reached two-thirds of its safety target, despite the deaths of 11 workers in the explosion and the subsequent massive oil spill. Overall, the five executives received about $900,000 in incentive bonuses; 25 percent of the bonus equation is determined by safety performance. Transocean reported that 2010 was its “best year in safety performance.”
Judge Orders Borders Bonus Plan Changes
Bankrupt bookseller Borders Group was ordered by U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Martin Glenn to revise its executive bonus plan after the lawyer representing unsecured creditors, Bruce Buechler, notified the judge that the plan rewarded executives for staying with the company though its bankruptcy. The plan had proposed giving the top five executives $4.9 million if unsecured creditors were paid at least $95 million, and a $1.8 million bonus if creditors received $73 million. Glenn instructed the retailer to include a provision that would apply if less than $73 million were returned to creditors.
Basel Establishes Criteria for Globally Essential Banks
The Basel Committee on Banking has established criteria designating banks that must maintain extra capital reserves because they are essential to global financial stability. The international regulatory committee did not compile a list of firms that these rules would affect. Banks will be evaluated based on “size, interconnectedness, substitutability, global activity and complexity,” said the committee’s secretary general, Stefan Walter, who noted that the Basel committee would monitor hedge funds, money market mutual funds and other securitization structures to help prevent another financial crisis.
Class Actions Lose, Arbitrators Win in Supreme Court Ruling
In a ruling expected to provide businesses with significant protections against class-action lawsuits, the Supreme Court ruled that state laws couldn’t override contract clauses that require customers to present complaints to private arbitrators individually. The case in question, AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion, fought over a $30.22 sales tax charge on phones that AT&T had advertised as “free.” The ruling makes arbitration clauses more attractive to companies in consumer contracts, and is expected to apply to employers in employee contracts under the Federal Arbitration Act of 2001.
Geronzi Resigns, Faces Ruling
Cesare Geronzi resigned as chairman of Italian insurer Assicurazioni Generali after the board threatened a vote of no confidence. He was awarded a payoff of 16.6 million euros ($24.3 million) upon leaving Europe’s No.3 insurer, according to Reuters. The controversial Italian financier has in succession chaired three of the country’s most important financial institutions: Capitalia; Mediobanca, which is Generali’s top shareholder; and Generali itself. Separately, a Rome court is due to rule on whether Geronzi contributed to the 2003 bankruptcy of Italian food group Cirio. Prosecutors are seeking an eight-year sentence for Geronzi, who has denied any wrongdoing.
Wall Street Banker Pay Falling
An unnamed Wall Street paymaster told The Wall Street Journal recently that the median banker pretax salary is currently $1.6 million, down from $2.2 million before the financial crisis hit. The pre-crisis pay was approximately 60 percent cash payments, with bankers taking home about $700,000 a year after taxes. Now, however, more bankers receive deferred compensation rewards, which brings their median aftertax take-home pay to about $380,000.
Director Shortage
Despite median director compensation increasing from $45,000 in 2001 to $119,500 in 2010, Canadian companies are having increasing difficulty finding directors to fill their boards. Spencer Stuart found “a definite increase in the number of first-timers joining boards,” said Andrew MacDougall, president of Spencer Stuart Canada. Over the past three years, almost 25 percent of all directors appointed were joining their first board. One-third of the newly appointed directors in 2010 were from the United States—the highest proportion since Spencer Stuart began tracking Canadian directorship trends. In addition, female board members increased to 20 percent in 2010, from 13 percent in 2009.
Top Paid CEOs in 2010
1. Philippe P. Dauman – Viacom
2. Lawrence J. Ellison – Oracle
3. Leslie Moonves – CBS
4. Martin E. Franklin – Jarden
5. Michael White – DirecTV
6. John F. Lundgren – Stanley Black & Decker
7. Richard C. Adkerson – Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold
8. Robert A. Iger – Disney
9. Donald J. Stebbins – Visteon
10. Jeffrey L. Bewkes – Time Warner
11. Alan Mulally – Ford Motor
12. Brian L. Roberts – Comcast
13. John H. Hammergren – McKesson
14. Samuel J. Palmisano – IBM
15. David M. Cote – Honeywell
16. Laurence D. Fink – BlackRock
17. James Dimon – JPMorgan Chase
18. David N. Farr – Emerson Electric
19. Thomas M. Ryan – CVS Caremark
20. Rex W. Tillerson – ExxonMobil
Source: The Wall Street Journal Survey of CEO Compensation
Corporate Reputations
Best:
1. Google
2. Johnson & Johnson
3. 3M Company
4. Berkshire Hathaway
5. Apple
6. Intel Corporation
7. Kraft Foods
8. Amazon.com
9. General Mills
10. The Walt Disney Company
Worst:
11. AIG
12. BP
13. Goldman Sachs
14. Citigroup
15. Chrysler
16. Bank of America
17. General Motors
18. ExxonMobil
19. JPMorgan Chase
20. Delta Airlines
Source: 2011 Harris Interactive